Pros and Cons of Tags
A balanced view of tag-based organization: the benefits of flexibility and cross-categorization versus the challenges of decision fatigue and recall.
Also known as: Tag Advantages Disadvantages, Benefits and Drawbacks of Tags, Tagging Trade-offs
Category: Principles
Tags: organizations, tags, pkm, information-management, best-practices
Explanation
Tags are a powerful organizational tool, but they're not inherently superior to folders or other methods. Understanding their advantages and disadvantages helps you use them effectively.
**Pros of Tags:**
1. **Multi-location existence**: Tags allow the same item to exist in more than one place at once without duplication. A note can be #productivity AND #writing AND #habits simultaneously.
2. **Speed of application**: Faster to type and use with autofill than dragging something into the correct folder hierarchy.
3. **Combinatorial retrieval**: Tags let you retrieve elements that match different combinations - find all notes that are both #project-x AND #urgent.
4. **Flexibility**: Easy to add new organizational dimensions without restructuring your entire system.
5. **Non-hierarchical**: Tags don't force artificial parent-child relationships that may not reflect reality.
**Cons of Tags:**
1. **Decision fatigue**: Everything has to be tagged. This requires tough decisions again and again whenever new items are added to the system.
2. **Recall vs. Recognition**: Remembering tags requires recall, something the brain is much worse at than recognition. You need to remember every single tag you've used and exactly how they're spelled/punctuated.
3. **Proliferation**: It's too easy to create tags, and thus too easy to create duplicates and end up with inconsistencies. Many terms exist for roughly the same concepts.
4. **System fragility**: Any change in interests, priorities, or focus can break the system. Tags that made sense before may not fit your current mental model.
5. **Stigmergy ignored**: Tags completely disregard environmental cues and force abstract categorization. You can't 'see' your tag structure the way you can see a folder hierarchy.
6. **Energy economics**: The energy required to tag every note often exceeds the energy required to run multiple searches when needed.
**Key Insight:**
Tags are no better or worse than folders, links, or MOCs. They're complementary. The best approach is usually a hybrid:
- Use folders for stable, broad categories
- Use tags for flexible, cross-cutting themes
- Use links for emergent connections
- Keep everything as simple as possible
Related Concepts
← Back to all concepts