Reasoning by Analogy
A thinking approach that solves problems by comparing them to similar situations and applying solutions that worked before.
Also known as: Analogical Reasoning, Analogical Thinking, Reasoning from Analogy
Category: Thinking
Tags: thinking, mental-models, problem-solving, reasoning, decision-making
Explanation
Reasoning by analogy is one of the most common and efficient forms of human reasoning. It works by identifying similarities between a current situation and past experiences or known domains, then transferring knowledge or solutions from the familiar to the new context.
**How It Works:**
1. **Recognize similarity** - Notice that the current problem resembles something familiar
2. **Map relationships** - Identify corresponding elements between domains
3. **Transfer knowledge** - Apply insights, solutions, or predictions from the known to the unknown
4. **Validate** - Check if the analogy holds and the transfer is appropriate
**Advantages:**
- **Efficiency:** Quick solutions without deriving everything from scratch
- **Communication:** Analogies help explain complex ideas ('the brain is like a computer')
- **Innovation:** Cross-domain analogies spark creative solutions
- **Learning:** Connects new knowledge to existing understanding
**Limitations:**
- **Inherited assumptions:** Copies both good practices and bad ones
- **False analogies:** Superficial similarities can mislead
- **Bounded thinking:** Limits solutions to variations of what exists
- **Missed opportunities:** May overlook fundamentally better approaches
**Contrast with First Principles:**
While first principles thinking questions all assumptions and builds from fundamentals, reasoning by analogy accepts existing frameworks and adapts them. Neither is universally better:
- **Use analogy** for routine decisions, incremental improvements, and communication
- **Use first principles** for breakthrough innovation, challenging industries, or when analogies keep failing
**Examples:**
- Designing a new product based on successful competitors
- Applying management practices from one industry to another
- Using biological systems to inspire engineering solutions (biomimicry)
Skilled thinkers know when to reason from analogy (fast, efficient) and when to question assumptions with first principles (thorough, innovative).
Related Concepts
← Back to all concepts