Dialogical Self
Hubert Hermans's theory that the self is a society of internal voices ('I-positions') that hold ongoing dialogues with one another, with no single voice having permanent authority.
Also known as: Dialogical Self Theory, I-Positions
Category: Psychology & Mental Models
Tags: psychology, identity, self-awareness, philosophy, communication, narrative
Explanation
Dialogical Self Theory, developed by Dutch psychologist Hubert Hermans starting in the 1990s, integrates William James's distinction between the *I* (the experiencing subject) and the *Me* (the self as object) with Mikhail Bakhtin's literary theory of polyphonic novels — works in which characters speak with autonomous voices that are not reducible to the author's view.
Applied to the self, this yields a striking proposal:
- The mind contains many **I-positions** — voices, perspectives, or characters that can speak as 'I' in inner dialogue. Examples: 'I as a professional,' 'I as my mother's child,' 'I as a future retired person,' 'I as an inner critic.'
- These positions argue, agree, ignore, dominate, and yield to each other over time. The self is the ongoing dialogue, not any one of the participants.
- Some I-positions are dominant in given contexts; others are silenced. Psychological flexibility involves giving more voices a fair hearing.
- Identity development is partly the integration of new I-positions (a new role, a new culture, a major loss) into the existing chorus.
Key distinctions and contributions:
- It bridges the personal (intra-mental dialogue) and the social (internalized voices of others) — a position is always at once mine and from a relationship.
- It treats inner conflict not as pathology but as the basic structure of self.
- It provides a vocabulary for cultural and bicultural identity: I-positions from different cultures coexist and dialogue.
Connections to the cluster:
- The [[stadium-of-selves]] is essentially a sports-metaphor cousin of dialogical self theory.
- [[internal-family-systems]] gives a more clinical instantiation; dialogical self gives a more linguistic/philosophical one.
- [[society-of-mind]] (Minsky) is the AI/cognitive-science version of the same intuition.
- [[illeism]] and [[self-distancing]] are tools for amplifying particular I-positions or for stepping outside the loudest one.
- The [[batman-effect]] can be read as deliberately strengthening a competent I-position in a moment when a more anxious one is dominant.
Dialogical Self has influenced research on identity development, multicultural psychology, narrative therapy, and coaching.
Related Concepts
← Back to all concepts